| Episode: | Episode 1: | Episode 2: | Episode 3: | Episode 4: | Episode 5: | Episode 6: | Episode 7: | Episode 8: | Episode 9: | Episode 10: | Episode 11: | Episode 12: | Episode 13 | Episode 14: | Third Place: | Runner-Up: | Sole Survivor: |
| Eliminated: | Jim 8/9 Votes | Morgan 8/9 Votes | Brianna 7/8 votes | Brooke 5/8 Votes | Blake 5/7 Votes | Margaret 6/7 Votes Brian 5/6 Votes | Amy 4/5 Votes | Brandon 6/10 Votes | Bobby Jon 6/9 Votes 1st Jury Member | Jamie 6/8 Votes 2nd Jury Member | Gary 6/7 Votes 3rd Jury Member | Judd 4/6 Votes 4th Jury Member | Cindy 4/5 Votes 5th Jury member | Lydia 3/4 Votes 6th Jury Member | Rafe 1 Vote 7th Jury Member | Stephenie 1/7 Jury Vote | Danni 6/7 Jury Votes |
| Danni | Jim |
|
|
| Blake | Brian | Amy | Jamie | Stephenie | Jamie | Gary | Judd | Cindy | Lydia | Rafe |
|
|
| Stephenie |
| Morgan | Brianna | Brooke |
| Margaret |
| Brandon | Bobby Jon | Jamie | Gary | Judd | Cindy | Lydia |
|
|
|
| Rafe |
| Morgan | Brianna | Brooke |
| Margaret |
| Brandon | Bobby Jon | Jamie | Gary | Judd | Cindy | Lydia |
| Stephenie |
|
| Lydia |
| Morgan | Brianna | Brooke |
| Margaret |
| Brandon | Bobby Jon | Jamie | Gary | Judd | Cindy | Danni |
|
| Danni |
| Cindy | Jim |
|
| Lydia |
| Margaret |
| Brandon | Bobby Jon | Jamie | Gary | Lydia | Rafe |
|
|
| Danni |
| Judd | Jim |
|
| Brooke |
| Margaret |
| Brandon | Bobby Jon | Gary | Gary | Lydia |
|
|
|
| Danni |
| Gary |
| Morgan | Brianna |
| Blake | Brian | Amy | Jamie | Cindy | Jamie | Cindy |
|
|
|
|
| Danni |
| Jamie |
| Morgan | Brianna | Brooke |
| Margaret |
| Brandon | Bobby Jon | Gary |
|
|
|
|
|
| Danni |
| Bobby Jon | Jim |
|
|
| Blake | Brian | Amy | Jamie | Stephenie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Danni |
| Brandon | Jim |
|
|
| Brian | Brian | Amy | Jamie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Amy |
| Morgan | Brianna |
| Blake | Brian | Bobby Jon |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Brian |
| Morgan | Brianna |
| Blake | Bobby Jon |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Margaret | Jim |
|
| Lydia |
| Judd |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Blake | Jim |
|
|
| Brian |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Brooke | Jim |
|
| Lydia |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Brianna |
| Morgan | Lydia |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Morgan |
| Lydia |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Jim | Margaret |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TRIBES:
Yaxha-Gary, Brianna, Rafe, Amy, Jamie, Morgan, Stephenie, Lydia, Brian
Nakum-Brandon, Danni, Blake, Brooke, Judd, Margaret, Jim, Cindy, Bobby Jon
Yaxha II-Gary, Amy, Brian, Brandon, Danni, Blake, Bobby Jon
Naxum II-Rafe, Jamie, Stephenie, Lydia, Brooke, Judd, Margaret, Cindy
Xhakum-Gary, Rafe, Jamie, Stephenie, Lydia, Brandon, Danni, Judd, Cindy, Bobby Jon
Stephenie and Bobby Jon were from Survivor: Palau before this.
ELIMINATION NOTES:
Jim-Although he was a good leader, Jim tore a muscle in his arm, making him detrimental to the tribe. He left 8-1.
Morgan-Lydia was the target, but Brian and Jamie, her allies, convinced Gary and Stephenie to lose Morgan, who didn't pull her weight. Morgan left 8-1.
Brianna-Brianna did badly in challenges and was voted off 7-1.
Brooke-Brooke was the weakest link of the Nakum members who had not swapped tribes. The four ex-Yaxha aligned with Judd, and Brooke left 5-3.
Blake-Blake was voted off to form team unity, because he only talked about himself. He left 5-2.
Margaret-Margaret was voted off 6-1 due to being an outsider.
Brian-Brian was physically weak, and too smart to keep in the game. He left 5-1 at the double elimination tribal council. (Margaret was the other victim.)
Amy-Yaxha didn't want to lose a member, but Amy was seen as the weakest, and left 4-1.
Brandon-At the merge, Brandon was hit with the triple whammy of being a threat, on the minority alliance, and Stephenie's urge to let Bobby Jon make the jury this time.
Bobby Jon-Because Gary had the individual Immunity Idol, the game was forced to shift gears. Bobby Jon was a challenge threat, and left 6-2-1.
Jamie-Jamie was very cocky after the merge. He calmed down, but was spreading lies about his alliance. Rafe gave up and convinced the tribe to vote off Jamie 6-2.
Gary-Gary was not in the 5-person alliance, and was a strong competitor. Gary exposed Judd's lie about the Immunity Idol, but he left 6-1 anyway.
Judd-Danni broke up the alliance by asking Rafe and Stephenie about Judd's trustworthiness. He was ousted 4-2.
Cindy-At the Reward, Cindy won a car. She got to choose between keeping the car for herself or giving one to all the other survivors. She kept the car, angering the tribe, and they voted her off 4-1. She also became the 10th Car Curse victim.
Lydia-Lydia left 3-1 because Danni, Steph, and Rafe knew she could beat anyone in the Final 2.
Rafe-Danni won the last Immunity, and knew she would win against Steph, so she ousted Rafe 1-0.
Stephenie-Stephenie had backstabbed too many people this time, and had already played the game before. She got the vote of Rafe the one person in her alliance she did not vote off.
Danni-Danni won 6-1 for fighting back from a minority alliance and not backstabbing too many people. She got the votes of Bobby Jon, Jamie, Gary, Judd, Cindy, and Lydia.