| Episode: | Episode 1: | Episode 2: | Episode 3: | Episode 4: | Episode 5: | Episode 6: | Episode 7: | Episode 8: | Episode 9: | Episode 10: | Episode 11: | Episode 12: | Episode 13: | Episode 14: | Third Place: | Runner-Up: | Sole Survivor: |
| Eliminated: | Jolanda 6/9 Votes | Ashlee 6/8 Votes | Jeff 4/7 Votes | Kim 5/6 Votes | Willard 8/9 Votes Angie 2/5 Votes | James 2/4 Votes | Ibrehem 2/3 Votes | Bobby Jon No Vote | Coby 7/9 Votes 1st Jury Member | Janu No Vote 2nd Jury Member | Stephenie 6/7 Votes 3rd Jury Member | Gregg 4/6 Votes 4th Jury Member | Caryn 4/5 Votes 5th Jury Member | Jennifer 2/2 Votes 6th Jury Member | Ian 1 Vote 7th Jury Member | Katie 1/7 Jury Votes | Tom 6/7 Jury Votes |
| Tom |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Coby |
| Stephenie | Gregg | Caryn | Ian | Ian |
|
|
| Katie |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Coby |
| Stephenie | Gregg | Caryn | Jennifer |
|
|
|
| Ian |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Coby |
| Stephenie | Gregg | Caryn | Jennifer |
|
| Tom |
| Jennifer |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Coby |
| Stephenie | Caryn | Caryn | Ian |
|
| Tom |
| Caryn |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Coby |
| Stephenie | Gregg | Ian |
|
|
| Tom |
| Gregg |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Coby |
| Stephenie | Caryn |
|
|
|
| Tom |
| Stephenie | Jolanda | Ashlee | Jeff | Kim | Bobby Jon | Ibrehem | Ibrehem |
| Coby |
| Caryn |
|
|
|
|
| Tom |
| Janu |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Stephenie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Tom |
| Coby |
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
| Janu |
|
|
|
|
|
| Katie |
|
| Bobby Jon | Angie | Ashlee | Kim | Kim | Angie | James | Ibrehem |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Ibrehem | Angie | Kim | Jeff | Kim | James | James | Stephenie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| James | Jolanda | Ashlee | Kim | Kim | Angie | Ibrehem |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Angie | Jolanda | Ashlee | Jeff | Kim | Bobby Jon |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Willard |
|
|
|
| Katie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Kim | Jolanda | Ashlee | Jeff | James |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Jeff | Jolanda | Ashlee | James |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Ashlee | Jolanda | Jeff |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Jolanda | Angie |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TRIBES:
Ulong-Kim, Bobby Jon, Ashlee, James, Jolanda, Stephenie, Jeff, Angie, Ibrehem
Koror-Coby, Janu,, Willard, Caryn, Tom, Ian, Katie, Gregg, Jenn(Stephenie later joined Koror)
Neither-Jonathan, Wanda
ELIMINATION NOTES:
Wanda and Jonathan-At the tribal selection phase, Wanda and Jonathan, the last man and women not on a tribe, were eliminated. Wanda annoyed the camp wth her singing and was perceived as the weakest female. Jonathan's early jump from the boat alienated him, and he hadn't seemed very friendly.
Jolanda-Was seen as too strong of a leader and caused friction on Ulong. She left 6-3.
Ashelee-Ashlee asked to be eliminated due to her sickness, and refused food. She was one of the weakest women, sending her out 6-1-1.
Jeff-Jeff hurt his ankle prior to the Immunity Challenge, and asked his tribe to lose him. Kim was supposed to leave, but Jeff went anyway, 4-2-1.
Kim-Kim was very lazy around camp and did poor at challenges. She left 5-1.
Willard-Even though Koror never lost an Immunity Challenge, both tribes had to lose someone. Willard's age and being a mental threat in the merge sent him home 8-1.
Angie-Once Ibrehem, who had cost Ulong the Reward Challenge, received Immunity from Koror, there was a tie, 2-2-1, between Angie and Booby Jon, with one vote for James. In a revote, Angie was sent home 3-0. This was probably because she was the weakest of the four non-immune Ulongs.
James-The friendship between Stephenie and Bobby Jon, James being a weak link in challenges, and BJ's mistrust of James caused a tie between James and Ibrehem, 2-2, but at the revote, Steph changed her vote, and James left 2-0.
Ibrehem-Since he was Ulong's weakest member, he went home 2-1. This was also because of the tribe being so small and Steph and BJ's friendship.
Bobby Jon-Since Stephenie and Bobby Jon's votes would have tied each other, they had a fire-making challenge to see who would be the last Ulong standing. Despite having known to make a fire longer than Stephenie, Bobby Jon lost, and was eliminated by elimination challenge.
Coby-Stephenie joined Koror, making the game individual. Coby posed a huge threat and schemed a lot, and left 7-1-1.
Janu-Stephenie was the target, but Janu had been close friends with Coby(at the Reunion, he had adopted his cousin's daughter, and he had named her Janu, after their friendship. Aww.) Janu quit the game, and since she was fed up with the game, her torch was not laid by a rock like Osten from Pearl Islands.
Stephenie-The last remaining Ulong member, Stephenie's time was up, and she left 6-1.
Gregg-Even though Caryn was supposed to go, Tom and Ian realized Gregg would vote them out. The two of them, Caryn, and Katie aligned and lost Gregg 4-2.
Caryn-The game was men against women, but Caryn revealed private conversation at Tribal Council. Feeling hurt, Katie, Tom, Ian, and Jenn ousted her 4-1.
Jenn-Tom, Ian, and Katie were going to lose Jenn, but Tom found out Ian was plotting against him, so he joined Jenn, and there was a tie, 2-2. Ian and Jenn had a fire-making challenge like that between Bobby Jon and Stephenie, and Jenn left by elimination challenge.
Ian-At the Final Immunity, Ian said that he would step down if Tom and Katie became friends again and he was voted out. Tom agreed, and at Tribal Council, Tom became the first Survivor to say his vote out loud, and Ian left 1-0.
Katie-Katie was more honest and less rehearsed than Tom, but the jury saw her as riding on coattails. She only got the vote of Coby.
Tom-Tom won 6-1. Tom had his tribe's respect, won 5 out of 7 individual challenges, and also was Koror's leader. With the possible exception of Moto, Koror is the most dominant tribe on Survivor. Tom got the votes of Ian, Jenn, Caryn, Gregg, Stephenie, and Janu.